Shoulder Instability: Causes, Treatment, and Recovery

Understanding Shoulder Instability

Shoulder instability occurs when the shoulder joint becomes loose, often due to injury or repetitive strain. This can lead to dislocations, subluxations (partial dislocations), and persistent pain or weakness. If left untreated, instability can significantly impact shoulder function and limit daily activities or athletic performance.

  • Traumatic Dislocation – Often caused by sports injuries, falls, or accidents, leading to ligament damage and, in some rare instances, fracture.
  • Repetitive Overuse – Common in overhead athletes (e.g., swimmers, football players, weightlifters) who place repeated stress on the shoulder.
  • Hyperlaxity – Some people have naturally loose ligaments, making them more prone to shoulder instability.
  • Shoulder dislocations event, whether self-reduced or requiring reduction by a medical provider
  • The feeling of the shoulder “slipping” out of place (i.e., subluxation events)
  • Pain, especially with overhead or pushing movements
  • Weakness and apprehension with certain movements and arm positions

Management of first-time shoulder dislocations has traditionally favored conservative treatment, such as immobilization and physical therapy. However, recent studies suggest that early surgical stabilization may be beneficial for high-risk individuals, including young patients, contact athletes, and laborers. A systematic review and meta-analysis by Belk et al. (2022) found that surgical stabilization for first-time anterior shoulder dislocation significantly reduced recurrent instability (6.3% vs. 46.6%, P < .00001) and the need for subsequent surgery (4.0% vs. 30.8%, P < .00001) compared to nonoperative treatment. Young active males seem to be at the highest risk and benefit the most from early surgical intervention. In the elderly, recurrent shoulder stability is less common, but patients may suffer rotator cuff tears. Early evaluation and discussion with an orthopedic surgeon is usually recommended to determine the best treatment plan.

For many patients, non-surgical management can restore stability and function:

If conservative treatments fail or if high risk after first dislocation, surgery may be needed to restore stability:

As a dual fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon specializing in shoulder conditions, Dr. Krueger offers advanced, personalized treatment options for shoulder instability. Whether you’re an athlete looking to return to peak performance or someone struggling with persistent pain and dysfunction, he has experience and expertise to help you regain stability and confidence in your shoulder.